Arsenal victim of erroneous decisions on three occasions
By OnzeActu · · 4 min read

Despite a series of contested refereeing decisions that denied Arsenal several legitimate penalties, the London team managed to preserve their lead in the Premier League. The Key Actions Review Board recently published its findings, including a major case against Hull City.
Why it matters
Arsenal victim of three incorrect penalty decisions in the Premier League carries wider implications for the teams, players, and competition context discussed in this report.
Key points
- Arsenal victim of erroneous decisions on three occasions.
- Despite a series of contested refereeing decisions that denied Arsenal several legitimate penalties, the London team managed to preserve their lead in the Premier League.
- Arsenal ba lần chịu thiệt vì phạt đền ở Ngoại hạng Anh - Báo VnExpress Thể thao.
The most recent case concerns the match at the Emirates Stadium on November 7 against Hull City. In the 42nd minute, Nobel Mendy clearly held off Kai Havertz in the box as the German striker tried to control the ball. After requesting VAR Michael Oliver, referee Farai Hallam went to watch the action, but ultimately refused the penalty due to Havertz's offside position. However, according to the official interpretation of the IFAB, offside does not justify removing the initial foul committed before the player's active participation in the phase of play. The KMI clearly establishes that this decision is erroneous and that Arsenal should have benefited from a penalty.
This decision comes in addition to two other similar errors that occurred during matches against Aston Villa (day 2) and Sunderland (day 3). Against Villa, a clash in the final moments between Ian Maatsen and Bruno Guimarães would have led to a penalty and an exclusion which were not whistled. In the match at Sunderland, a penalty awarded to the locals was deemed unjustified, adding to the refereeing controversy at the start of the season.
Officials at the London club, including coach Mikel Arteta, expressed their incomprehension over these decisions. Arteta had even observed the sequence 20 times without being able to explain the penalty not awarded against Sunderland.
Image
Notably, despite these unfair decisions, Arsenal won all three of these matches, consolidating their position as the league leaders. The team also benefited from a controversial penalty in their win over Liverpool in early November, where a foul on Alexander Isak was not penalized.
Across all examinations, the KMI noted a correct decision rate of 86% on the pitch and 97% including VAR, but emphasizes that the errors against Arsenal are among the most notable.
The current season once again illustrates the challenges of using video in football, questioning both training and refereeing protocols. For Arsenal, these decisions remain a hot topic as the title fight heats up.
(Image source: Kai Havertz during Arsenal - Hull City, VnExpress)
The rest
The next phase should bring official updates, squad decisions, and a clearer picture of what this means on the pitch.