Really, Mbappé?
By OnzeActu · · 5 min read
Aleix Parisé questions the legitimacy of Kylian Mbappé for the Ballon d'Or, believing that several players have a more convincing track record and individual season than the Frenchman.
Why it matters
The question of Kylian Mbappé's legitimacy at the Ballon d'Or highlights the selection criteria for this prestigious award. Individual performances, while remarkable, must often be weighed against collective success, as illustrated by the journey of players such as Lamine Yamal, who won several major titles this season. This analysis could influence voters' and fans' perceptions of the value of Mbappé's achievements compared to other candidates.
Context
Kylian Mbappé, star striker of PSG, is often considered one of the best players on the planet. However, his recent lack of collective titles with the Parisian club raises questions about his place among the Ballon d'Or contenders. Compared to young talents like Lamine Yamal, who have already won major trophies, Mbappé must prove that he can also contribute to significant collective successes.
Key points
- Really, Mbappé?.
- Aleix Parisé questions the legitimacy of Kylian Mbappé for the Ballon d'Or, believing that several players have a more convincing track record and individual season than the Frenchman.
- ¿De verdad, Mbappé?, by Aleix Parisé.
The central argument is simple: Mbappé has “two blank years with Real Madrid” and, even if he has scored numerous goals, these have not translated into collective titles. On the basis of this observation, Parisé compares the Frenchman's file to that of other candidates who, in his eyes, present superior results.
First example cited: Lamine Yamal. At just 19 years old, Yamal is a world champion, La Liga champion and winner of the Spanish Super Cup. His statistical contribution – 24 goals and 17 assists with FC Barcelona according to the article – is presented as decisive for the success of his club and the Spanish selection. These collective and individual achievements are, for the author, a strong argument in favor of the candidacy of the young Spaniard.
Parisé also mentions names like Dembélé or Kvaratskhelia, emphasizing that any important player who has been a European champion should logically collect more votes than Mbappé. The argument is based on a simple logic: collective trophies weigh heavily in the appreciation of a season.
Image
Fabián Ruiz is mentioned for a specific reason: he would be, among the nominees mentioned, the only one to have won the Champions League and the World Cup in the same year, a double which, according to the author, should count enormously in the votes.
Harry Kane is also among the players that Parisé considers superior to Mbappé. Kane won the Golden Boot with 36 goals in the Bundesliga, compared to 25 for Mbappé in La Liga according to the text. He reached the Champions League semi-finals after knocking out Real Madrid in the quarters, and had a solid World Cup with six goals, clinching third place with England after a victory over France in the third-place match.
Finally, Rodri is cited as another contender likely to be placed in front of Mbappé, especially after being elected best player (MVP) of the World Cup, again according to the original article. Parisé concludes on a provocative note: if the Ballon d'Or went to a player who had two seasons without a trophy, it would, according to him, be "the biggest scandal in world football."
The exercise proposed by the author is clear: remember that the Ballon d'Or, beyond individual statistics, has a lot to do with collective titles and performances in major competitions. On the eve of the vote, the question remains open: should the individual crown take precedence over the collective record?
The rest
As the Ballon d'Or debate continues, Mbappé's performances in the upcoming matches with PSG and in the Champions League will be closely scrutinized. His ability to transform his goals into collective success will be crucial to strengthening his candidacy. At the same time, other players like Dembélé and Kvaratskhelia will continue to shine at their respective clubs, which could also influence the final vote.
Frequently asked questions
Why is Kylian Mbappé being discussed as a candidate for the Ballon d’Or?
Kylian Mbappé is considered a leading candidate for the Ballon d'Or due to his performances, although he is criticized for failing to win collective titles with Real Madrid.
Who analyzed Mbappé's candidacy for the Ballon d'Or?
The analysis of Mbappé's candidacy was made by Aleix Parisé, who believes that he should not even appear on the final podium.
What are the arguments against Mbappé's candidacy?
Arguments against Mbappé's candidacy include his "two blank years with Real Madrid" and the
fact that his goals did not lead to collective titles.
Which other players are mentioned as candidates for the Ballon d'Or?
Other players mentioned include Lamine Yamal, Dembélé and Kvaratskhelia, all of whom have collective and individual records rated as superior.
Why is winning the Champions League important for the Ballon d'Or?
Victory in the Champions League is important because collective trophies weigh heavily in the appreciation of a season, influencing votes for the Ballon d'Or.