Qui est impliqué dans l'échange de joueurs ?

Dwight McNeil d'Everton et Brennan Johnson de Crystal Palace sont impliqués dans cet échange.

D'où vient Brennan Johnson ?

Brennan Johnson vient de Crystal Palace, où il a été transféré pour 35 millions de livres.

Pourquoi Crystal Palace échange-t-il Dwight McNeil ?

Crystal Palace échange Dwight McNeil pour intégrer Brennan Johnson dans leur effectif.

Quel est le statut financier de l'échange ?

L'échange doit respecter les règles financières de la Premier League, et la valorisation de chaque joueur influencera le coût total pour chaque club.

Quand l'échange sera-t-il officiel ?

L'échange doit obtenir l'aval de la Premier League, mais la date exacte de l'officialisation n'est pas précisée.

Who is Dwight McNeil in this story?

Dwight McNeil is the main player involved in this transfer rumor update.

What is the player's current situation?

The article discusses Dwight McNeil's situation based on the latest reporting.

← Back to news

International

Premier League: what are the rules for exchanges of

By OnzeActu · il y a environ 1 mois · 5 min read

A swap move between Everton and Crystal Palace has been announced for Dwight McNeil and Brennan Johnson. Premier League rules explained: recording as two separate transfers, impact on squad cost ratio and fair market value checks.

According to Bbc.

Context

Everton winger Dwight McNeil is set to join Crystal Palace in a swap deal that could also see Brennan Johnson head to the Toffees. This type of transfer, although rare, underlines the evolution of the recruitment strategies of Premier League clubs, which seek to optimize their workforce while respecting the financial rules in force.

Why it matters

The exchange between Dwight McNeil and Brennan Johnson illustrates the complexities of the Premier League transfer market, where even unusual transactions must adhere to strict rules. The valuation of each player in this exchange will influence not only the clubs' finances, but also their ability to navigate the summer transfer window. Managing the squad cost ratio is crucial to ensuring the financial viability of clubs in the Premier League.

Key points

Premier League: what are the rules for trading.
A swap move between Everton and Crystal Palace has been announced for Dwight McNeil and Brennan Johnson.
Premier League: What are rules on player swaps in the transfer window? - BBC Sport.

An exchange between Premier League clubs, although it remains uncommon, is legal and can be concluded during transfer periods. This is precisely the case of the file which associates Everton and Crystal Palace: Dwight McNeil should join Crystal Palace, while Brennan Johnson would be integrated into the Toffees squad. But on an administrative and financial level, such a “swap” does not escape the same rules as “classic” transfers.

Technically, the league records a trade as two separate transfer transactions. Each of them therefore falls within the scope of the Premier League's financial controls and rules, in particular the squad cost ratio (SCR) – the indicator used by the league to assess the sustainability of squad-related expenses. The valuation assigned to each player in the operation will directly influence these calculations.

Image

The specific case mentioned by observers clearly illustrates the issue: Brennan Johnson cost Crystal Palace 35 million pounds upon his arrival. For the swap to be accounting neutral on the Eagles' side, his value under the swap would need to be closer to around £30m. If, on the other hand, the valuation used is lower – McNeil's file having already seen an estimate of 20 million pounds circulated when a transfer to Selhurst Park failed in February – this could translate into an accounting loss for Palace of around 10 million pounds if the two players are listed at 20 million each.

In addition to the impact on the accounts, all exchanges must obtain approval from the Premier League for the control of “fair market value” (FMV) and associated party transactions (APT). These rules, introduced in 2021, aim to protect the financial stability, integrity and competitive balance of the championship. To assess whether a transaction reflects market value, the league uses external evaluation companies which take into account criteria such as the player's age, his level of performance and comparable operations.

The final decision on the conformity of an exchange therefore rests with the Premier League, which can validate or refuse the operation if it considers that the declared valuation is not consistent with market indicators. In summary: swaps are authorized but scrutinized and counted as separate transfers, with real consequences on the financial balances of the clubs concerned.

The rest

As the Everton-Crystal Palace swap looms, both clubs will need to ensure player evaluations meet Premier League standards. If McNeil's valuation is lower than Johnson's, Crystal Palace could face a significant accounting loss. Clubs will also need to prepare for possible adjustments to their squad and player development strategy based on the results of this exchange.